Finding the right dog for you
From apartment-friendly breeds to high-energy companions, learn how to match a dog to your lifestyle, family, and budget.
Understanding dog breed groups
Dogs have been selectively bred for thousands of years to perform specific tasks. Understanding these breed groups gives you insight into the natural tendencies and behaviors you can expect.
Sporting dogs
Bred for hunting alongside humans, sporting dogs are typically:
- Highly trainable and eager to please
- Active and energetic (they need regular exercise)
- Good-natured and sociable
- Excellent family dogs when properly exercised
Best for: Active individuals or families who enjoy outdoor activities and have time for daily exercise.
Hound dogs
Originally bred for hunting by scent or sight:
- Can be independent thinkers (sometimes called "stubborn")
- Often have strong prey drives
- Scent hounds may follow their nose anywhere; sight hounds have bursts of energy
- Generally friendly but may be less eager to please than sporting dogs
Best for: Patient owners who appreciate an independent spirit and can provide secure, fenced areas.
Working dogs
Bred for jobs like guarding, pulling, and rescue:
- Strong, intelligent, and confident
- Need a job to do or they'll find their own "work"
- Often large and powerful
- Require experienced handling and consistent training
Best for: Experienced dog owners with space, time for training, and leadership skills.
Terrier dogs
Originally bred to hunt vermin:
- Feisty, energetic, and determined
- Can be vocal and scrappy
- Often fearless regardless of size
- May have strong prey drives toward small animals
Best for: Active owners who enjoy a dog with personality and don't mind a little sass.
Toy dogs
Bred primarily for companionship:
- Portable and adaptable to small spaces
- Personalities vary widely (some are feisty, others are laid-back)
- May be fragile and not ideal for homes with young children
- Often devoted and bond closely with one person
Best for: Apartment dwellers, seniors, or anyone wanting a dedicated lap companion.
Herding dogs
Bred to manage livestock:
- Extremely intelligent (often too smart for their own good)
- High energy with strong work drive
- May try to "herd" children or other pets
- Excel in training and dog sports
Best for: Active owners who can provide mental stimulation and physical exercise daily.
Non-sporting dogs
A diverse group with varied histories:
- Wide range of sizes, temperaments, and energy levels
- No single trait defines this group
- Research individual breeds carefully
Best for: Varies widely. Research specific breeds in this category.
Not sure which breed group fits you? Take our quick quiz
Key factors in choosing a dog
1. Energy level match
This is perhaps the most critical factor in long-term happiness, both yours and your dog's.
Low energy
30-45 min daily • Bulldogs, Basset Hounds, Shih Tzus
Moderate
1-2 hours daily • Labrador, Golden, Beagle
High energy
2+ hours daily • Border Collie, Husky, Vizsla
Extreme
3+ hours daily • Belgian Malinois, Weimaraner
The number one reason dogs end up in shelters
Owners underestimating a breed's exercise needs is one of the leading causes of surrendered dogs. A bored, under-exercised dog will develop behavioral problems that can seem unmanageable.
2. Living space
While any dog can adapt to various living situations, some are naturally better suited to specific environments.
Best for apartments:
- Smaller dogs (but not all small dogs, Jack Russells are tiny but incredibly active)
- Lower energy breeds
- Dogs with minimal barking tendencies
- Breeds that don't require a yard for bathroom breaks
Best for houses with yards:
- Larger breeds with room to stretch
- Dogs that enjoy outdoor play
- Breeds that benefit from more space to roam
A well-exercised Great Dane in a one-bedroom apartment will be calmer than a bored Border Collie in a mansion. It's not about square footage, it's about meeting the dog's needs.
3. Family considerations
With young children (under 8):
- Choose patient, tolerant breeds
- Avoid fragile toy breeds that could be injured
- Consider adopting an adult dog with known temperament
- Supervision is essential regardless of breed
| Trait | Good with Kids | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Labrador Retriever | Patient, playful, sturdy enough for kids | |
| Golden Retriever | Gentle, affectionate, loves family activities | |
| Beagle | Friendly, sturdy, good size for families | |
| Bulldog | Calm, patient, loves low-key play | |
| Border Collie | Great with active families, may herd children | |
| Chihuahua | Too fragile for young children |
With other pets:
- Research breed-specific tendencies (terriers may chase cats)
- Consider adopting a dog known to live with other animals
- Plan for careful introductions regardless of breed
4. Grooming requirements
Grooming isn't just about aesthetics. It's a time and financial commitment.
| Coat Type | Grooming Needs | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Short, smooth | Weekly brushing, occasional baths | Beagle, Boxer, Labrador |
| Double coat | Frequent brushing, heavy seasonal shedding | Husky, German Shepherd, Corgi |
| Long, silky | Daily brushing, regular professional grooming | Maltese, Afghan Hound, Shih Tzu |
| Curly/wool | Minimal shedding, professional grooming every 6-8 weeks | Poodle, Bichon, Doodle mixes |
| Wire/rough | Hand-stripping or clipping, moderate maintenance | Terriers, Schnauzer |
Allergies and coat type
No dog is truly hypoallergenic, but low-shedding breeds like Poodles, Bichons, and some terriers produce fewer allergens. Spend time with a breed before committing if allergies are a concern.
5. Health considerations
Some breeds are predisposed to certain health conditions. Understanding these risks helps you:
- Budget for potential veterinary costs
- Choose appropriate pet insurance
- Make informed decisions about breeders (who should health-test their dogs)
Breeds with common health concerns:
- Bulldogs: Breathing issues, overheating, joint problems
- German Shepherds: Hip dysplasia, degenerative myelopathy
- Cavalier King Charles Spaniels: Heart disease, syringomyelia
- Dachshunds: Back problems (intervertebral disc disease)
- Golden Retrievers: Cancer, hip dysplasia
Find breeds that match your lifestyle
Our quiz considers your living situation, activity level, family, and preferences to recommend breeds with compatible health profiles and care needs.
Breeder vs. rescue vs. shelter
Reputable breeders
Pros:
- Predictable size, appearance, and temperament
- Health testing of parent dogs
- Support throughout the dog's life
- Can meet parents and see breeding conditions
Cons:
- Higher cost ($1,000-$3,000+ for most breeds)
- May have waitlists
- Requires research to find ethical breeders
Avoiding puppy mills
Never buy from pet stores, websites with multiple breeds "always available," or breeders who won't let you visit. Reputable breeders ask questions, require contracts, and genuinely care about their puppies' futures.
Rescue organizations
Pros:
- Often know the dog's personality from foster care
- May include spay/neuter, vaccinations, and microchip
- Breed-specific rescues for purebreds
- Lower cost than breeders
Cons:
- Limited availability of puppies
- Unknown health or genetic history
- Some dogs may have behavioral challenges from past experiences
Shelters
Pros:
- Saving a life
- Lower adoption costs ($50-$300 typically)
- Often includes basic vetting
- Staff can help match personality
Cons:
- Less information about background
- May have unknown behavioral or health issues
- Purebreds are less common
Questions to ask before getting a dog
Before bringing a dog home, honestly answer these questions:
- Can I commit to 10-15 years of care? Dogs are a long-term responsibility.
- Do I have 1-2+ hours daily for exercise, training, and companionship? Even lower-energy dogs need attention.
- Can I afford $100-$300+ per month for food, vet care, and supplies? Plus emergency fund for unexpected costs.
- Is my housing situation stable and pet-friendly? Moving with a dog can be challenging.
- Who will care for my dog when I travel? Boarding or pet sitting adds up.
- Am I prepared for the puppy stage? Or should I consider an adult dog?
The right dog will fit into your life as it actually is, not as you wish it were. Choose with your head first, and your heart will follow.
Puppy vs. adult dog
Puppies (under 1 year)
Advantages:
- Bond from the start
- Shape behavior through training
- Experience all life stages together
Challenges:
- Time-intensive training and supervision
- Housebreaking takes months
- Chewing, biting, and chaos
- Unknown adult temperament
Adult dogs (1-7 years)
Advantages:
- What you see is what you get (personality is established)
- Often house-trained
- Past the destructive puppy phase
- Can still bond deeply
Challenges:
- May have unknown history
- Could have established behaviors to work through
- Less time together overall
Senior dogs (7+ years)
Advantages:
- Calm and settled
- Grateful and loving
- Lower exercise needs
- A wonderful option for older adopters
Challenges:
- Higher likelihood of health issues
- Less time together
- May have special care needs
Making your final decision
After researching breeds and considering your lifestyle, you're ready to take the next step:
- Narrow down to 3-5 breeds that match your lifestyle
- Meet dogs of those breeds at shows, rescue events, or through breeders
- Talk to owners in online communities or in person
- Consider fostering if available in your area
- Take our quiz for personalized recommendations based on your specific situation
Ready to find your match?
Take our 2-minute quiz and get personalized breed recommendations with compatibility scores based on your lifestyle, living situation, and preferences.
Final thoughts
Finding the right dog is one of the most rewarding searches you'll ever undertake. When you find a match where your dog's needs align with what you can provide, you're setting up both of you for years of happiness.
Take your time. Do your research. Be honest about your lifestyle. And when you're ready, you'll know.
The right dog is out there waiting for you.